Sonic Youth Gossip

Sonic Youth Gossip (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/index.php)
-   Non-Sonics (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/forumdisplay.php?f=5)
-   -   Israel vs the rest of the middle east (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/showthread.php?t=4097)

Bastian 07.14.2006 05:40 PM

http://www.israel-un.org/sec_council...14july2006.htm
Statement by the israeli ambassador to the UN before the Security Council:

Quote:

[..] Lebanon is today occupied by terror, whether in the south, where it is directed at Israel, or in Beirut, where it kills opponents of Syria and former prime ministers. The real occupying power in Lebanon is terror – terror instigated by Hizbullah but initiated, funded and perpetrated by Syria and Iran.

The Lebanese government, having missed so many chances in the past, at such a horrendous cost to its people, today has another chance to free itself from the stranglehold of terror. Another chance, Mr. President, to release itself from the evil control of Syria and the deadly influence of Iran, and deploy its forces in the south, exercising its sovereignty over a free Lebanon.

Mr. President,
There are words that speak far louder and clearer than anything I can voice today. These are voices of Lebanese – brave, patriotic Lebanese parliamentarians and ministers – who just over the last two days have cried out to all of us from the brink of the abyss in their beloved country. Let me quote some of these courageous statements. The words of Lebanon’s communication minister, Mr. Maruan Hammuda, saying only yesterday that “Damascus gives the orders, Iran supplies the equipment, Israel reacts, Lebanon is the victim.”

Or the words of Elias Attallah, a Lebanese politician representing a majority of its parliament members: “ We welcome any Arab and international support but strongly oppose any enforced involvement of Lebanon by regional players’ considerations (a reference to Syria and Iran) that are not within the interests of the Lebanese people for the sole attempt to achieving opportunistic benefits at the expense of the Lebanese people…The Syrian regime indulges itself in teaching Lebanon and Palestine lessons according to its own interests through these peoples. Why do those who always protect this regime express understanding of its reasons and preferences and do not express any understanding of Lebanon’s reasons and preferences?”

Or the words of an unnamed Lebanese minister, who said, “The Hizbullah has not only kidnapped two Israeli soldiers, it has taken the whole of Lebanon hostage.”

Mr. President,
With your permission, I would like to make a personal appeal to my esteemed Lebanese colleague.

Your Excellency,
You know, deep down, that if you could, you would add your voice to those of your brave countrymen. You know, deep down in your heart, that you should really be sitting here, next to me, voicing the same opinion. You know that what we are doing is right, and, if we succeed, your country will be the real beneficiary. I am sure many of our colleagues around this table and in this chamber, including many or our neighbours, share this sentiment.

Mr. President,
This Council and the international community have a duty today to help the Lebanese people achieve the goal of a free, prosperous and democratic Lebanon. The sad and tormented life of this war-torn land has today entered another sad chapter in its history. It is up to every one of us to help write this chapter, to ensure that this opportunity is seized, not only for the benefit of the Lebanese and Israeli people, but for the sake of generations to come.
Thank you Mr. President.

afreespirit 07.14.2006 05:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tokolosh
I refuse to take sides, but let's not forget that Dimona's Negev Nuclear Research Center can be a reason for Iran and others arming themselves. Israel's nuclear capability is not to be underestimated and extremely worrying to neighbouring countries.
Even the US had their doubts as to what was going on in Dimona when it was first built.


Iran isn't quite a neighbouring country to Israel.

Tokolosh 07.14.2006 06:43 PM

Literally they're not, no, but a threat never the less. Remember the first gulf war and the Iraqi scuds reaching Israeli soil? Long range missiles are abundant in those parts of the world.

jon boy 07.15.2006 08:42 AM

yeah we should know we sold them to most of them along with russia.

'whats that? your nation has a terrible record on human rights and shows contempt for all around. have some of these weapons'

bytheriver 07.15.2006 10:40 AM

Ok I didnt read much past page four but Im fairly familiar with both sides of this interminable debate, i just wanted to reply to a couple of the earlier statements about choosing sides etc, as well as the whole left right thing. I just think its about time that sort of thing stops, your enemies enemy is not your friend, ideologically Im pretty left but cant support any leftist parties because of all the bloody Socialists, these people refuse to accept the USSR as a bad entity because it was the enemy of the US, they gloss over Cambodia, China, North Korea etc just cause they represent an alternative. And they still call each other Comrade in meetings which makes them impossible to take seriously. Anyway factionalism and choosing sides is the key ingredient in conflict, whats needed is third party moderators and neutral influences to calm shit down, like international institutions or non politically alligned organisations, or popular movements of the people.
In terms of this situation people always immediately choose sides and demonise the other, no attempt at understanding is made. Israel supporters dont recognise the poverty, occupation, loss of land and refugee crisis as legitimate grievances. Supporters of Palestinians/Arabs refuse to recognise Israels security concerns, or the historic foundations for their sensitivity. Both sides claim to be right. Dogmatic refusal to understand or emphathise with the enemy gets people nowhere.

I personally think in this case the onus is on Israel to withdraw to 1967 borders, I think all their peace deals etc are token gestures without that being done. But that doesnt make them a target for civilian attacks, suicide bombings and rocket attacks on population centres arent justified by that. Likewise responses that do the same. And round and round.

Tokolosh 07.15.2006 10:43 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bytheriver
Ok I didnt read much past page four but Im fairly familiar with both sides of this interminable debate, i just wanted to reply to a couple of the earlier statements about choosing sides etc, as well as the whole left right thing. I just think its about time that sort of thing stops, your enemies enemy is not your friend, ideologically Im pretty left but cant support any leftist parties because of all the bloody Socialists, these people refuse to accept the USSR as a bad entity because it was the enemy of the US, they gloss over Cambodia, China, North Korea etc just cause they represent an alternative. And they still call each other Comrade in meetings which makes them impossible to take seriously. Anyway factionalism and choosing sides is the key ingredient in conflict, whats needed is third party moderators and neutral influences to calm shit down, like international institutions or non politically alligned organisations, or popular movements of the people.
In terms of this situation people always immediately choose sides and demonise the other, no attempt at understanding is made. Israel supporters dont recognise the poverty, occupation, loss of land and refugee crisis as legitimate grievances. Supporters of Palestinians/Arabs refuse to recognise Israels security concerns, or the historic foundations for their sensitivity. Both sides claim to be right. Dogmatic refusal to understand or emphathise with the enemy gets people nowhere.

I personally think in this case the onus is on Israel to withdraw to 1967 borders, I think all their peace deals etc are token gestures without that being done. But that doesnt make them a target for civilian attacks, suicide bombings and rocket attacks on population centres arent justified by that. Likewise responses that do the same. And round and round.


Agreed.

alyasa 07.15.2006 11:33 AM

And round and round...

afreespirit 07.15.2006 11:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tokolosh
Literally they're not, no, but a threat never the less. Remember the first gulf war and the Iraqi scuds reaching Israeli soil? Long range missiles are abundant in those parts of the world.

Remember the Iran/Iraq war? Iran's nuclear program was started as a deterrant to Saddam. They have made a lot of threats towards Israel over the years, none of them defensive in nature.

Bastian 07.15.2006 05:45 PM

Quote:

Saudi Arabia blames Hizbollah in Lebanon crisis
RIYADH (Reuters) - Saudi Arabia on Thursday blamed "elements" inside Lebanon for the violence with Israel, in unusually frank language directed at guerrilla group Hizbollah and its Iranian backers.

"A distinction must be made between legitimate resistance and uncalculated adventures undertaken by elements inside (Lebanon) and those behind them without recourse to the legal authorities and consulting and coordinating with Arab nations,"

[..]

Major Arab governments other than Syria are not expected to give unqualified backing Hizbollah, or the Palestinian militant group Hamas which is holding an Israeli soldier hostage.

http://uk.news.yahoo.com/13072006/32...on-crisis.html

Wow, that`s quite surprising, in a positive way.
I`m pretty opposed to Saudi government, but their stance on the Lebanese/Israeli conflict sounds pretty reasonable.

space_monkey 07.15.2006 05:55 PM

Israel---terorrist Number 1. ! ! ! !

alyasa 07.15.2006 11:59 PM

Die, space_monkey...

Tokolosh 07.16.2006 07:14 AM

Word!

space_monkey 07.17.2006 04:26 AM

fuck off alyasa!!can you see how many civilians have israels army killed in 3 day ,so fuck off stupid bitch!!

krastian 07.17.2006 04:33 AM

Both sides do shady shit man......if people would either say fuck yr old religion or have some God damn respect (since they are so Holy) for other people/religion then there wouldn't be all of this shit going down because of boredom.....get a life or stop by my place for the party you bastids. WAKE UP.

Florya 07.17.2006 08:39 AM

I heard that 8 Canadians were killed in an Israeli air raid in Lebanon yesterday.
Maybe now that Israel has made it clear that they don't care who they kill, the International community will finally start trying to organise a cease fire.

BTW did anyone hear Bush's 'off air' solution to the crisis?
He thought his mike was off, and was talking to Blair whilst eating his lunch. The conversation went thusly:
Bush - "What they need to do is get Syria to get Hizbollah to stop doing this shit and it's all over"

Blair - "Hmmm"

I wonder if that's the message Condi will be taking with her when she visits the area.

Tokolosh 07.18.2006 05:28 AM

Looks like this shit is escalating...

_slavo_ 07.18.2006 05:52 AM

...and it looks like it's not ever going to end.

atari 2600 07.18.2006 09:09 AM

Was Bush's mic faux pas staged or really real?
On a related note, has anyone seen the unwelcome massage that Bush gave to German Chancellor Angela Merkel?

I also find it a bit curious how every time "Hezbollah rockets" are mentioned, the Iranian connection is rightly made, but every time "Israeli warplanes" are mentioned, no one bothers to report that these are undoubtably F-16 fighters that the U.S. sold Israel.

Today, the early coverage is of the helicopter carrier USS Iwo Jima that has been sent to escort chartererd cruise ships carrying Americans (& other evacuees?) & also help pick-up those in Lebanon that want to leave. What the news isn't telling everyone is that refugees are being asked by the U.S. State Department to sign a promissory note, for which they are billed later for around three hundred dollars, plus the interest on the note.

Tokolosh 07.18.2006 09:19 AM

This has already lasted longer than 6 days....
I saw what florya mentioned about the g8 footage where Bush and Blair were talking privately with the mics still on. Fucking gunslinging cowboys is what they are!

Tokolosh 07.18.2006 09:35 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by atari 2600
Was Bush's mic faux pas staged or really real?
On a related note, has anyone seen the unwelcome massage that Bush gave to German Chancellor Angela Merkel?


 
 
 

WTF? This guy doesn't know how to keep his hands to himself! :mad:

ricechex 07.18.2006 10:11 AM

holy shit that is so weird. i saw that. it's kinda funny and he probably meant it in a "let me lighten this place up" way. he's the political frank drebin from naked gun. but this is a fuckin international G8 meeting about a serious war in the middle east. ya know? the dude doesn't care about anything but the power that comes along with being the most powerful man in the world.

he still hasn't asked for a cease fire. it's the right thing to do, regardless of anything. And it's a complete tacid arrangement with the hardliners in israel that are feeling threatened by the rapid rise of radical islamists, risen ironically by bush's hopeless push for democracy in that region through force. let it happen naturally. its the only way. don't lie about WMD and turn into democracy for all. like i say, people r too smart for that. one of the first things a lebonese woman said on tv after israel killed her family was "this is bush's fault" , ranting about the U.S policy, the west policy, not anything about israel directly..that is how terrorism is bred.

Bastian 07.18.2006 10:29 AM

Isnīt it about time to change the title of this thread into "Hizbollah vs. the rest of the middle east"?!

http://www.jpost.com/servlet/Satelli...cle%2FShowFull

Quote:

With the exception of the Palestinians, the Arab world appears to be united in blaming Iran and Syria for the fighting in Lebanon. Until last week, Arab political analysts and government officials were reluctant to criticize Hizbullah in public. But now that Hizbullah Secretary-General Hassan Nasrallah and his top aides are in hiding, an anti-Hizbullah coalition is emerging not only in Lebanon, but in several other Arab countries as well.[..]

Tokolosh 07.18.2006 10:37 AM

Most people in Lebanon don't give a shit about Hezbollah and have never voted for them. Those cunt's are just as bad as the Israeli forces that are invading. They hide in civilian populated areas and think that the Israeli forces won't dare to bomb the suburbs flat.

atari 2600 07.18.2006 10:48 AM

yeah "most" --- 55% Tokolosh, but er ah...Tony Blair just made the same misleading statement you just did when he addressed Paliament today.

An estimated 45% of citizens of Lebanon are Shiite fundamentalists & support Hezbollah. The current fighting is sure to push those numbers into the majority, as planned.

In Iraq we saw "free & democratic elections" basically translate to Sunni disenfranchisement & a push that elected a Shiite state-sponsored hardline Muslim extremist government just like neighbor Iran. This same trend will continue throughout the Middle East as the U.S. supposedly fights for "freedom" & instead engenders a new, much larger wave of anti-Zionist terrorists.

If one wants to boil all this down & distill it, then the basic substance of it all is that the U.S. is manipulating things to help the Shias gain a great amount of power in the whole mideast region. We are in league with them covertly & have been since Reagan. The push is being made to create a real terrorist enemy, much more substantial than the rag-tag al-Queda. It seems the DOD, the DOE, the military-industrial complex, & corrupt politicians want to be sure to create a scenario by which they can continue to pass bloated budgets that they can siphon & steal from at will. As the world has reached peak oil & the shit is certainly about to hit the fan in the coming years, those that are in power are making a mad grab for as much money as they can get their grubby hands on & if one addresses it properly, the same politicians can always villify the concerned critic by pointing a finger right back at them...you see, it's the "perfect" crime. Back during the cold war, one was a "commie" if they criticized U.S. policy. These days, one is labelled a "terrorist sympathizer" if they spread the truth that could threaten the activities of the thieves.

Florya 07.18.2006 10:50 AM

I have no problem with Israel going after the Hizbollah guys that are firing rockets from the southern border of Lebanon into northern Israel.

That would be self defence.

What I find offensive is Israel's deliberate targetting of civilian infrastructure like power stations and fuel depots, the deliberate targetting of legitimate and highly visible aid convoys that include ambulances, telling civilians to leave their villages and then targetting their cars and trucks when they do.

My feeling is that Israel has been waiting for an excuse to take revenge on Lebanon for the bitchslap they were given in 2000.

This is not Israel v Hizbollah, this is Israel v Lebanon.

This will go on til Lebanon is fucked.
Hezbollah will never disappear. Attacking terrorist organisations only makes them stronger if you look at the history of the region.

Why doesn't Bush want a ceasefire?

Look at it this way - Israel is killing Arabs. The US supports Israel when they kill Arabs. Israel needs weapons with which to kill Arabs. The US supplies Israel with weapons. Israel gives the US lots of money for those weapons. That money goes towards funding the Iraq fiasco where, surprise surprise, the US is killing Arabs.

Rumsfeld and Cheney must be laughing their asses off!

Florya 07.18.2006 10:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by atari 2600
the U.S. is manipulating things to help the Shias gain a great amount of power in the whole mideast region. We are in league with them covertly & have been since Reagan. The push is being made to create a real terrorist enemy, much more substantial than the rag-tag al Qaida


Good point Atari. Hadn't thought of that.

sonicl 07.18.2006 11:01 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by atari 2600
Was Bush's mic faux pas staged or really real?


I wondered that too.

Lurker 07.18.2006 11:05 AM

[quote=Bastian]Isnīt it about time to change the title of this thread into "Hizbollah vs. the rest of the middle east"?!
[quote]

It's Hesballah

Bastian 07.18.2006 11:11 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Florya
Hezbollah will never disappear. Attacking terrorist organisations only makes them stronger if you look at the history of the region.


Not attacking terrorist organisations is what makes them stronger. If a terrorist organisation is losing important personal all the time and needs to replace it`s leaders every few months, this will make it harder for them to function.



Quote:

Look at it this way - Israel is killing Arabs. The US supports Israel when they kill Arabs. Israel needs weapons with which to kill Arabs. The US supplies Israel with weapons. Israel gives the US lots of money for those weapons. That money goes towards funding the Iraq fiasco where, surprise surprise, the US is killing Arabs.

Pretty weak argument. There`s more money to make in selling arms to hunderts of millions of arabs, whose countries own plenty of oil, than to the tiny state of Israel.

Surprise, surprise: In Iraq, most arabs (and mostly arab civilians that is) are killed by: arabs! The USA is trying to prevent this, and sacrifices american soldiers for it. What do you think would happen after a premature pull-out from Iraq? Most likely civil war. That`s why America is putting it`s soldiers into danger to enable the Iraqi democracy to get stronger, to rebuild it`s army and police force, and to eventually (hopefully soon) be able to control Iraq on it`s own, without US support.

atari 2600 07.18.2006 11:13 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Florya

Rumsfeld and Cheney must be laughing their asses off!


On 9/11, Rumsfield was in NYC at a meeting of the board of directors of The Carlyle Group, a prominent military contractor. Perhaps he was laughing his ass off as he watched the events unfold because the plan was coming together.

On 9/11, Cheney is reported to have been giving the order to stand down at NORAD in Colorado, essentially telling our military that it was "all a drill." Whether it's true or not is not clear, but some ex-employees & their lawyers also maintain that they are still being hounded by the CIA for spilling those particular beans.

Bastian 07.18.2006 11:13 AM

[quote=Lurker][quote=Bastian]Isnīt it about time to change the title of this thread into "Hizbollah vs. the rest of the middle east"?!
Quote:


It's Hesballah

Sorry, I was using a different transliteration.
Well, actually it`s this, anyways:

‮حزب الل

atari 2600 07.18.2006 11:20 AM

There's lots of acceptable anglicized spellings, but all in all, I'm just trying to ignore Bastian's posts.

"Those who cannot learn from history are doomed to repeat it."
- George Santayana

Bastian 07.18.2006 11:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by atari 2600
There's lots of acceptable anglicized spellings, but all in all, I'm just trying to ignore Bastian's posts.


Well, that`s probarly easier than discussing about the points I raise.

atari 2600 07.18.2006 11:25 AM

I have found from previous political threads that engaging in debate with someone that merely parrots the media's perspective is about as effective as banging my head against a wall.

My words will stand just as yours will & the reader will decide.

How about that for a novel concept?

I have no use for the endless post-quoting & all that eventual crap as the thread gets polluted with muck.

To that end, you have just been placed on my ignore list.

Lurker 07.18.2006 11:26 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bastian
[


حزب الل

Right, well I'll spell it like that from now on.

Bastian 07.18.2006 11:28 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lurker
Right, well I'll spell it like that from now on.


Oh, seems like your computer does not support arabic writing. Sorry about that.

porkmarras 07.18.2006 11:30 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by atari 2600
I have found from previous political threads that engaging in debate with someone that merely parrots the media's perspective is about as effective as banging my head against a wall.

My words will stand just as yours will & the reader will decide.

How about that for a novel concept?

I have no use for the endless post-quoting & all that eventual crap as the thread gets polluted with muck.

To that end, you have just been placed on my ignore list.

That's why i don't engage with such threads in the first place.There are more interesting ways to do your bit rather than the internet.And that's a fact.

Bastian 07.18.2006 11:36 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by atari 2600
I have found from previous political threads that engaging in debate with someone that merely parrots the media's perspective is about as effective as banging my head against a wall.

My words will stand just as yours will & the reader will decide.

How about that for a novel concept?

I have no use for the endless post-quoting & all that eventual crap as the thread gets polluted with muck.

To that end, you have just been placed on my ignore list.


Allright. Thanks for the "simpleton" though (nice quick edit job!).
Even though you can`t read me anymore now. Itīs so much easier with your head in the sand, isn`t it.

"Merely parroting the media", allright. Too bad now you`ll never tell me were you get your informations and views from. By reading the media and thinking the exact opposite? Or what media I`m parroting exactly, since there seem to be a lot different, sometimes quite opposed positions to this whole situation in the media. Oh well..

atari 2600 07.18.2006 04:21 PM

Yeah, porkmarras, I'm just a slow learner, whereas we all know of your probing insights & far-reaching political activism. You people slay me.

Quote:
Originally Posted by atari 2600
Was Bush's mic faux pas staged or really real?


Quote:

Originally Posted by sonicl
I wondered that too.


In the open mic "glitch" from a couple of days ago Bush named "Syria" not "Iran" & today, in a press conference he mentioned Syria, like, three times, & Iran zero times.

Tokolosh 07.18.2006 06:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by atari 2600
yeah "most" --- 55% Tokolosh, but er ah...Tony Blair just made the same misleading statement you just did when he addressed Paliament today.

An estimated 45% of citizens of Lebanon are Shiite fundamentalists & support Hezbollah. The current fighting is sure to push those numbers into the majority, as planned.

In Iraq we saw "free & democratic elections" basically translate to Sunni disenfranchisement & a push that elected a Shiite state-sponsored hardline Muslim extremist government just like neighbor Iran. This same trend will continue throughout the Middle East as the U.S. supposedly fights for "freedom" & instead engenders a new, much larger wave of anti-Zionist terrorists.

If one wants to boil all this down & distill it, then the basic substance of it all is that the U.S. is manipulating things to help the Shias gain a great amount of power in the whole mideast region. We are in league with them covertly & have been since Reagan. The push is being made to create a real terrorist enemy, much more substantial than the rag-tag al-Queda. It seems the DOD, the DOE, the military-industrial complex, & corrupt politicians want to be sure to create a scenario by which they can continue to pass bloated budgets that they can siphon & steal from at will. As the world has reached peak oil & the shit is certainly about to hit the fan in the coming years, those that are in power are making a mad grab for as much money as they can get their grubby hands on & if one addresses it properly, the same politicians can always villify the concerned critic by pointing a finger right back at them...you see, it's the "perfect" crime. Back during the cold war, one was a "commie" if they criticized U.S. policy. These days, one is labelled a "terrorist sympathizer" if they spread the truth that could threaten the activities of the thieves.


I actually agree with you about many of the points you made but it's nothing new. It doesn't take a genius to figure it out and the information is out there if you look in the right places. What I'm tired of hearing are all these conspiracy theories (probably true to some extent) about this or that plan the US government and some if not all European countries have up their sleeves when it comes to the middle east and their oil. The fact is that you and I will never know what's really going on behind the curtain and I think you're being pretty arrogant in this discussion by stating that I or others parrot the media's perspective. We are here to exchange ideas and hopefully find some truthful answers, not argue about how much each of us knows.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:50 PM.

Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
All content Đ2006 Sonic Youth