Sonic Youth Gossip

Sonic Youth Gossip (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/index.php)
-   Non-Sonics (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/forumdisplay.php?f=5)
-   -   Lou Reed marries Laurie Anderson (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/showthread.php?t=21436)

Rob Instigator 04.25.2008 12:25 PM

sonic youth draws fans with all ranges of musical tastes, from those that love classic rock, to those for whom sonic youth is the most "normal" band they listen to.

floatingslowly 04.25.2008 12:32 PM

rob, please enjoy this wonderful goat. hopefully, it replaces the one you've recently lost.
 

Rob Instigator 04.25.2008 12:43 PM

You have confused me, yet again floatingslowly.


goat?

floatingslowly 04.25.2008 12:55 PM

yes. it appears that a few of the posters above have got yrs.

just sayin'.

Rob Instigator 04.25.2008 01:51 PM

does it not appear that my bad mouthing of laurie ;overrated" anderson got atari's goat? what exactly got mine?

floatingslowly 04.25.2008 02:10 PM

don't drag me into this!

however, since you don't want it, I'll be keeping that goat for myself.

there's lots of things goats are good for.....on dark and lonely nights.

anyways....sorry. carry on please. the drama was just starting to get good.

floatingslowly 04.25.2008 02:11 PM

on topic:

I plan to see these guys in Dallas on May 21st.

I hope they play Synchronicity II. I fucking love that song.

mangajunky 04.25.2008 02:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by floatingslowly
on topic:

I plan to see these guys in Dallas on May 21st.

I hope they play Synchronicity II. I fucking love that song.


Laurie Anderson and Lou Reed might play Synchronicity II?

floatingslowly 04.25.2008 02:26 PM

Lou Reed's playing with them???

omg.

This Is Not Here 04.25.2008 02:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rob Instigator
what "approach?" the old hag's been around forever, and I have been around forever, and I have heard a lot of her crap, and seen several of her crap performances, and they were pure wankery. her "artistic output" sucks major ass (in my OPINION of course)

I do nto see how being a sonic youth maniac fanatic has anything to do with laurie anderson.


Firstly, "old hag": age has nothing to with it, and shes only six years older than the oldest member of SY. And y'know, I just find it bizarre of that your favourite band just released 30 minutes of droning noise and most people on the forum would have payed £10 to hear it, and yet you seem so abhored by Anderson's comparatively more accessible take on experimental music. I love all experimental music and would never call it pure pretentious wankery, but surely Rob if anything is pretentious wankery SYR7 and much of SY's output is just that. And yet, here you are on a Sonic Youth forum. Does this seem bizarre to anyone else?!

Rob Instigator 04.25.2008 03:03 PM

fuck the semantics man. I hate her performances and I hate her music.

I love sonic youth's performances and I love their music. it's as simple as that. just opinions you know.

atari 2600 04.25.2008 03:05 PM

Gee, it's too bad Laurie doesn't have big tits and/or a big ass, or she might have a fan in Rob.

But to sum up, you're such an embodiment of a macho stereotype, misogynistic tendencies and all, that you fail to see the forest for the trees. I mean, it's readily obvious.

I hardly think such an unreasonably strong term as "hate" should be directed at Laurie Anderson repeatedly from any open-minded person, especially one that otherwise enjoys a lot of cool music.

This Is Not Here 04.25.2008 03:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rob Instigator
fuck the semantics man. I hate her performances and I hate her music.

I love sonic youth's performances and I love their music. it's as simple as that. just opinions you know.


I understand its your opinion dude, and your not obliged to like her. But as a clear fan of experimental music claiming Anderson to be pretentious wankery and that being a reason for not liking her... is beyond strange.

!@#$%! 04.25.2008 03:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by This Is Not Here
I understand its your opinion dude, and your not obliged to like her. But as a clear fan of experimental music claiming Anderson to be pretentious wankery and that being a reason for not liking her... is beyond strange.


i never heard of cheeto being a fan of "experimental" anything, so i'm not sure how that's clear.

and even if he was, i dont' see the incoherence--

and even if it was incoherent-- so??

--

ps- sorry, for those of you who are new, cheeto = rob

This Is Not Here 04.25.2008 03:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by !@#$%!
i never heard of cheeto being a fan of "experimental" anything, so i'm not sure how that's clear.

and even if he was, i dont' see the incoherence--

and even if it was incoherent-- so??

--

ps- sorry, for those of you who are new, cheeto = rob


sonic youth are experimental music

mangajunky 04.25.2008 03:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by This Is Not Here
I understand its your opinion dude, and your not obliged to like her. But as a clear fan of experimental music claiming Anderson to be pretentious wankery and that being a reason for not liking her... is beyond strange.


Something can be experimental and not pretentious and vice versa. Rob made similar comments about Philip Glass, why aren't you defending him as vehemently? Perhaps the sexism is on your own side. Just because someone attacks a woman's work it doesn't make him a misogynist.

atari 2600 04.25.2008 03:26 PM

Personally, I did state that I like Philip Glass okay for what he does. And I stated my case on that account.

And it's not like I'm gonna prove that Rob has strong misogynistic tendencies, but it's also, as I stated before, readily obvious that he indeed does routinely demonstrate those very tendencies to those paying any sort of estimable attention.

Take it for what it's worth. The dude is an okay guy, as guys usually go, but ultimately, he's a self-serving ass. There was never a need for him to write in this thread that she sucked or that he hated her, and moreover, there is even less credibility to possibly be gleaned for repeating the same dumb, obnoxious shit over and over in this wedding thread.

have

you

lost

your

dog

?

This Is Not Here 04.25.2008 03:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mangajunky
Something can be experimental and not pretentious and vice versa. Rob made similar comments about Philip Glass, why aren't you defending him as vehemently? Perhaps the sexism is on your own side. Just because someone attacks a woman's work it doesn't make him a misogynist.


I did not, at any point, call him a misogynist.

This Is Not Here 04.25.2008 03:27 PM

Laurie Anderson Is In The Rugrats Movie


Fact

Rob Instigator 04.25.2008 03:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by atari 2600
Gee, it's too bad Laurie doesn't have big tits and/or a big ass, or she might have a fan in Rob.

But to sum up, you're such an embodiment of a macho stereotype, misogynistic tendencies and all, that you fail to see the forest for the trees. I mean, it's readily obvious.

I hardly think such an unreasonably strong term as "hate" should be directed at Laurie Anderson repeatedly from any open-minded person, especially one that otherwise enjoys a lot of cool music.


"hate" is an apt description for the rage and venom that ensues every single time I have to listen to or watch Laurie anderson. I actively HATE IT, just like I actively hate when I have to sit and hear Counting Crows.
I never attacked YOU personally, yet you attacked me, see?
I don;t like it when people bad mouth sonic youth but they are free to do so, even on sonic youth's own forum.

✌➬ 04.25.2008 03:33 PM

What's the problem here?

Rob Instigator 04.25.2008 03:41 PM

I made fun of somebody's momma it looks like ;)

✌➬ 04.25.2008 03:43 PM

Oh ok, carry on.

gmku 04.25.2008 03:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by atari 2600
Whoa! Wild nuptial news! (You know, wedding guest Julian Schnabel (sous chef-turned-'80s art star) directed Basquiat, and most recently The Diving Bell and The Butterfly.)
__________________



 





 





 


They look like a real nice quiet couple. Like people I'd want for my next-door neighbors.

!@#$%! 04.25.2008 03:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by This Is Not Here
sonic youth are experimental music


sonic youth are rock

add some noise--

still rock

!@#$%! 04.25.2008 03:59 PM

ps

Experimental music

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Jump to: navigation, search
For experimental rock music, see experimental rock.
"Avantgarde music" redirects here. For the record label, see Avantgarde Music.
Experimental music is a term introduced by composer John Cage in 1955. Cage defined "an experimental action is one the outcome of which is not foreseen" (Cage 1961, 39), and he was specifically interested in completed works that performed an unpredictable action (Mauceri 1997, 197) In a broader sense, it has come to mean any music that challenges the commonly accepted notions of what music is. Avant-garde music is another term for it. David Cope describes experimental music as that, "which represents a refusal to accept the status quo" (Cope, 1997, 222).

etc etc bla bla bla

---
so when i hear "silver rocket" begin, i already know how it's going to end

same with the diamond sea

same with new hampshire

same with all the pop-infested rather ripped

it's not "experimental"

it's rock.
 

mangajunky 04.25.2008 04:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by !@#$%!
---
so when i hear "silver rocket" begin, i already know how it's going to end

same with the diamond sea

same with new hampshire

same with all the pop-infested rather ripped

it's not "experimental"

it's rock.
 


Unless you're seeing them live. Then it can go in all sorts of directions.

!@#$%! 04.25.2008 04:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mangajunky
Unless you're seeing them live. Then it can go in all sorts of directions.


throw in some noise improvisation in the middle, just like guitar solos have done since the beginning of time, just like jazz or descargas, they return to the song, it's always a song, "experimental" my pompous ass. rock.

pbradley 04.25.2008 04:03 PM

You people prove that language is a virus.

!@#$%! 04.25.2008 04:04 PM

(from outer space)

--
unrelated:

i love big science btw. my favorite record for cleaning house.

gmku 04.25.2008 04:11 PM

Actually, Laurie Reed looks a little like me, come to think of it. Hmm...

nicfit 04.25.2008 04:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by !@#$%!
throw in some noise improvisation in the middle, just like guitar solos have done since the beginning of time, just like jazz or descargas, they return to the song, it's always a song, "experimental" my pompous ass. rock.

have you ever seen teenage riot as a set ender, or nyc ghost and flowers, or the ultra famous Hallucinogenic preserve's the diamond sea?
seeing thurston screaming rolling on the floor while almost swallowing a mic and lee jumping on a little amp with sorta tibetan bells ringing hanging from his hands while smiling and waving at the audience isn't much of a "return to the song"....Maybe this is not the "standard definition of experimental" (which is, imho, a contraddiction in itself), but it sure isn't that predictable, unless you think saying "oh, now they'll do something strange with that thing" lessens the impact of their actions, but this could be applied to any kind of music.
All of this has nothing to do with laurie anderson, just my take on sy live.

gmku 04.25.2008 04:28 PM

Sonic Youth isn't real experimental but it sure can sound pretty sometimes.

pbradley 04.25.2008 04:30 PM

You're right guys, there's nothing experimental at all about sticking screwdrivers under the strings or alternative tunings.

gmku 04.25.2008 04:32 PM

I'm just being sardonic. Of course they're experimental. To an extent. Some of their stuff is more than others. Some of their stuff once was experimental but now seems tame because it's been copied so much.

pbradley 04.25.2008 04:45 PM

I've never assumed that experimental music has to be harsh or absolutely never done before. Experimental music, to me, is discovering music for one's self. It's pretty retarded for the listening audience to call something experimental just because they haven't heard it before. The audience could have heard it before but that doesn't change the fact that the artist discovered the sound totally for his or her self. It appears to me that a lot of experimental fans get caught up with the novelty of something new instead of the different ways it can be applied. Gimmick lovers. Though Rather Ripped is not as radical as SY's early output, I can still hear their experimental results being born through their calmer sound which, to me, is still experimental. The foundations are their own creation, everything built upon it (no matter how accessible) still bares the premise.

Rob Instigator 04.25.2008 04:51 PM

experimental is an adjective, and it can precede any musiacl genre you can thin of.

experimental symphionc music

experimental rock

experimental jazz

etc.

Glice 04.25.2008 05:01 PM

Someone recommend me a Laurie Anderson record. I've always thought everything I heard was tripe, but I've not heard much. So I'm looking to be converted.

Phillip Glass, meanwhile, is capable of some fine stuff but has also turned out more shit albums than most people turn out albums.

This Is Not Here 04.25.2008 05:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Glice
Someone recommend me a Laurie Anderson record. I've always thought everything I heard was tripe, but I've not heard much. So I'm looking to be converted.

Phillip Glass, meanwhile, is capable of some fine stuff but has also turned out more shit albums than most people turn out albums.


Your the Guy I Want To Share My Money With with Burroughs is very good, but her real seminal release is Big Science.

atari 2600 04.25.2008 05:34 PM

You're the Guy I Want to Share My Money With (the split release with Burroughs and Giorno) contains some United States Live. Ubuweb has the whole, raw thing for download or streaming.
http://www.ubu.com/sound/guy.html

As essential as Big Science is, and I do recommend it as perhaps her best overall, United States Live I-IV, the four-disc compression of the six-hour BAM performance piece, is a must as well. Big Science, in many ways, is a further compression of this piece worked up as a single-disc studio album.

Mister Heartbreak (a fan favorite for many) and the live (they share some material) Home of the Brave soundtrack are more musical. It's tough to say which you may like best.

I'd recommend viewing Home of the Brave. There's also a Collected Videos release on VHS. Both are, at long last, getting the dvd treatment soon with extras. Also forthcoming is a boxed set of videos and rarities.

One that I think people would like is the spared-down, anecdote and tale-based The Ugly One With the Jewels And Other Stories. It's a charmer from a live concert. Whereas Live at Town Hall is probably more indicated ifyou're already a fan.

And, as mentioned previously in the thread, Bright Red has some interesting textures, but there's more than a fair amount of misses in there too; "The Puppet Motel" from that one has some monster bass. Similarly, her first foray into real singing on Strange Angels (her most in times and at parts conventionally musical album as well) is not all fully conceived, but on "The Day The Devil," the track more suited to her range, the result is particularly sweet. Some of the other ones are hauntingly beautiful though, even if she isn't technically much of a good singer. Somehow, I think that Strange Angels, which came out in '89, may be the album that some of you first heard, and yeah, I can understand dismissal in that case. I was a fan, and I felt let down by it myself back then.

Accompanied by a group of performers that handle much of the vocal duties and originally planned as a release, her Songs And Stories From Moby Dick only exists as a two-disc FM from an '00 Barbican Theater performance, but it's well worth seeking.

The new one, Homeland, appears this summer.

So, that's that...for what it's worth. Although, someone that labels Laurie as "tripe" obviously is hearing her on a very surface level complete with biases and preconceived notions anyways and not really absorbing the "difficult music" on much of a meaningful level. As listeners know, she often artfully employs humor, lest her themes become too preachy (the newest one, "Only An Expert," is much more directly preachy than usual). And as flippant as Laurie may seem at times, she is an artist with a genuine vision and, as an inspirational exception to the rule, she is truly sincere and vigilant which is something that cannot be stated about too many others so conclusively.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 12:39 PM.

Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
All content ©2006 Sonic Youth